Current issues of ACP Journal Club are published in Annals of Internal Medicine


Resource Corner

Bandolier's Little Book of Pain

PDF

ACP J Club. 2004 Jan-Feb;140:A14. doi:10.7326/ACPJC-2004-140-1-A14



Here is evidence to support the old adage that “good things come in small packages.”Bandolier's Little Book of Pain is a convenient pocket size, yet its 450 pages are packed with useful, current information about analgesia, evidence-based practice, and patient care. This book is clearly and humorously written in the Bandolier style and will appeal to everyone involved in managing and delivering pain relief.

Pain is an important, common, and often undertreated condition, with enormous social and financial consequences. As a result, there are many good reasons for reading Bandolier's Little Book of Pain. For instance, U.K. figures indicate that 10% of the population experiences pain daily; adverse drug reactions involve analgesics more than any other group; and back pain alone results in the loss of 52 million workdays in the United Kingdom each year and a substantial cost to health services as well. Using this book not only raises awareness of issues surrounding pain, it provides a framework for identifying and applying evidence-based, patient-specific solutions.

The book comes from the Pain Research Group at the Churchill Hospital in Oxford and includes material from their Web site (www.jr2.ox.ac.uk/bandolier/booth/painpag/index). Commercial sponsorship to enable this work is acknowledged. Good introductions to the philosophy of evidence-based practice, nature of pain, and methodology of trial design help to make the text accessible: an important strength, as pain control is often delivered by teams, and this book has something to inform all team members. Subsequent chapters discuss acute and chronic pain, migraine, arthritis, and cancer pain. There are also chapters for complementary therapies and management issues. Discussions of specific (and occasionally controversial) interventions are accompanied by a critically appraised systematic review. Throughout, the emphasis is on “tools not rules,” but the strongly evidence-based examples are difficult to argue with. When clear evidence is not available, the authors refer to the wisdom of experience, particularly that of patients.

This is a practical book for front-line care. It promotes meaningful, measurable outcomes, while acknowledging the importance of quality of life, convenience, and compliance. Patient control and “rescue” strategies are emphasized. Results are expressed as relative risks or number needed to treat with a confidence interval and supported by graphs and references. Advice on critically appraising pain research will help users interpret and incorporate future advances in analgesia.

I enjoyed reading this book, which flowed naturally from one informative discussion to the next. My favorite observation was a comment by Gertrude Stein: “For a difference to be a difference, it has to make a difference.” This book certainly made a difference for me as a general practitioner, particularly in the current atmosphere of controlled prescribing. My only criticism is that although the table of contents is clearly laid out, the book lacks an index. The result is a delay in accessing some “bottom lines.” Nonetheless, it has a place within arm's reach when I consult and is a useful aid for rational prescribing and informed patient choice.

William S.M. Summerskill, MBBS, MSc
University of Bristol
Bristol, England, UK

Ratings

Methods/Quality of Information: 5 of 5 stars

Clinical Usefulness: 5 of 5 stars

Bandolier's Little Book of Pain can be purchased online at www.oup.co.uk for £19.99.