Current issues of ACP Journal Club are published in Annals of Internal Medicine


Therapeutics

Hypericum extract was better than placebo and equivalent to imipramine for moderate depression

PDF

ACP J Club. 2000 July-Aug;133:12. doi:10.7326/ACPJC-2000-133-1-012


Source Citation

Philipp M, Kohnen R, Hiller KO. Hypericum extract versus imipramine or placebo in patients with moderate depression: randomised multicentre study of treatment for eight weeks. BMJ. 1999 Dec 11;319:1534-9. [PubMed ID: 10591711]


Abstract

Question

In patients with moderate depression, how do the effectiveness and safety of Hypericum extract (St. John’s wort) compare with those of imipramine and placebo?

Design

8-week randomized {allocation concealed*}†, blinded (clinicians and patients),* placebo-controlled trial.

Setting

18 general practitioners’ practices in Germany.

Patients

263 patients who were 18 to 65 years of age (mean age 47 y, 75% women) and had a diagnosis of moderate depression; score of ≥ 18 on the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS); clinical global impression rating of moderate, marked, or severe; and depression lasting ≥ 4 weeks and ≤ 2 years. Exclusion criteria included bipolar disorders, alcohol or drug dependence, or suicidal risk. 230 patients (87%) completed the study; 251 (95%) were included in an intention-to-treat analysis.

Intervention

Patients were allocated to Hypericum extract (STEI 300, Steiner Arzneimittel, Berlin, Germany), 1050 mg/d (n = 106); imipramine, 50 mg/d titrated to 100 mg/d by day 5 (n = 110); or placebo (n = 47).

Main outcome measures

The primary end point was change from baseline in HDRS score. Hypericum was compared with placebo at 6 weeks and with imipramine at 8 weeks.

Main results

At 6 weeks, greater improvement from baseline occurred with Hypericum extract than with placebo (mean decrease in HDRS score of 13.4 vs 10.3, 95% CI for the 3.1 difference 1.5 to 5.4). At 8 weeks, Hypericum extract and imipramine had similar changes in score from baseline (mean decrease of 15.4 vs 14.2, CI for the 1.2 difference -0.6 to 2.6). More patients who received Hypericum extract had ≥ 50% improvement in HDRS scores than did patients who received placebo {P = 0.027}‡; the proportions did not differ between Hypericum and imipramine {P = 0.14}‡ (Table). Fewer patients in the Hypericum group than the imipramine group reported adverse effects {P < 0.001}‡ (Table).

Conclusion

In patients with moderate depression, Hypericum extract (St. John’s wort) was more effective than placebo and as effective and safe as imipramine.

*See Glossary.

†Information provided by author.

P values calculated from data in article.

Source of funding: Steiner Arzneimittel, Berlin, Germany.

For correspondence: Dr. K.O. Hiller, Steiner Arzneimittel, D-12207 Berlin, Germany. FAX 49-30-712-5012.


Table. Hypericum extract (HE) vs placebo at 6 weeks and HE vs imipramine (Imi) at 8 weeks for moderate depression§

Outcomes Comparison Event rates RBI (95% CI) NNT (CI)
≥ 50% improvement in HDRS score HE vs placebo 67% vs 48% 40% (3.5 to 101) 6 (3 to 50)
HE vs Imi 76% vs 67% 14% (-4.3 to 37) Not significant
RRR (CI)
Adverse effects HE vs Imi 22% vs 46% 53% (30 to 69) 4 (3 to 9)

§HDRS = Hamilton Depression Rating Scale. Other abbreviations defined in Glossary; RBI, RRR, NNT, and CI calculated from data provided by the author.


Commentary

The trial by Philipp and colleagues suggests that Hypericum extract may be considered as a treatment for moderate depression in primary care. To determine whether to prescribe Hypericum, some issues should be addressed.

The conclusion that Hypericum extract is safe in the long term is premature because of the limited duration of the study. Most patients are treated for many months. The fact that no data are available on concomitant pathology and drug treatments preclude statements about drug interactions. It has been shown that Hypericum induces the cytochrome P450, which might have serious clinical implications, for instance, in HIV-infected patients on protease inhibitors (1). Interactions with such other drugs as cyclosporin (2), warfarin, theophylline, and some contraceptives have been reported (3). Furthermore, such common foods as grapefruit influence the same enzyme system (3). Future studies might consider using a crossover design, comparison with a selective serotonin-reuptake inhibitor, or a higher dose of imipramine.

Hypericum perforatum is an herbal remedy that, although it is widely used and has promising results in this trial, is not yet completely understood. Because Hypericum products may vary considerably in composition, prescribers should be aware that study results may not be generalized to other extracts.

Etienne Vermeire, MD
University of Antwerp
Antwerp, Belgium


References

1. Piscitelli SC, Burstein AH, Chaitt D, Alfaro RM, Falloon J. Indinavir concentrations and St John’s wort. Lancet. 2000;355:547-8.

2. Ruschitzka F, Meier PJ, Turina M, Luscher TF, Noll G. Acute heart transplant rejection due to Saint John’s wort. Lancet. 2000;355:548-9.

3. Ernst E. Second thoughts about safety of St John’s wort. Lancet. 1999;354:2014-6.